Showing posts with label Critical Thinking. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Critical Thinking. Show all posts

Monday, 28 July 2014

Never Stop Learning: conceptual reasoning

Never Stop Learning
The most important skill we teach in our MBA programme is "thinking," a skill refined with practice, just like riding a bike or learning to play a musical instrument. We emphasize conceptual reasoning as a central theme across all of our courses (along with character) and as the foundation for independent, lifelong learning: it works like this.

We ask students to interact with a relevant professional or academic literature (e.g., marketing, finance, sustainability), so they ground their thinking in a respected body of knowledge accumulated over time. This is in contrast to relying on the experiences of one lifetime, a very small N of observations leading to faulting reasoning. We teach our students to analyze (not read descriptively) each article or assigned chapter to grasp how the author defines core concepts and the logic he or she constructs. Note, this expedites their reading. They learn to interact with a literature (any literature) and critique the coherence of logic / arguments presented, a valuable skill. This grounding in a professional literature offers a firm foundation; our student's ability to critique logic enables them to additively advance knowledge; and their ability to reason through concepts enhances the integrity of their own arguments, either in writing or in-class discussions.

Then, our students distinguish between (1) grounding their thinking in an established body of knowledge, and (2) using of this knowledge in analyzing data, with data defined as written case studies, live cases (real corporate clients) and personal experiences. The body of knowledge they bring to data analyses allows our students to impose a structure on noisy data, with noise defined as opinion, irrelevant observations, faulty reasoning, and so forth. And the structure they impose drives the analyses they conduct to address critical questions informing solutions to the complex problems businesses face. In the most elaborate extension of this reasoning ability (e.g., our capstone 540 consulting engagement), our students gather hard (e.g., financial or operating numbers) and qualitative (e.g., industry expert interviews) data to support the construction of a well-crafted, coherent argument backed by data supporting their reasoning.

It is my opinion (N of some number of observations) that many academics and practitioners lack the discipline to think powerfully, as I have just described. And, I would argue that the value of an advance degree like the MBA comes from improving the students' reasoning abilities, a skill that generalizes well to any applied context...and lasts a lifetime. Go ahead, critique my argument.

Wednesday, 25 June 2014

Meet Term Two Lecturers: Sergio Biggemann

Dr. Sergio Biggemann
I would like to introduce Sergio a veteran Otago MBA lecturer with four years of experience teaching marketing in our programme. Biggemann holds a Doctor of Business Administration from Macquarie Graduate School of Business (MGSM) at Macquarie University in Sydney, Australia.  He also holds a Master of Business Administration and a Master of Management and Public Policy from the Catholic University of Bolivia (both with Distinction) and a bachelor’s degree in Mining Engineering.

Sergio brings extensive practical business experience into the classroom. Originally from Bolivia, he spent twenty years in mining and related industries. He is a co-founder and was general manager of a mining company, a terotechnology company, a silver-ware crafting company in Bolivia. Founded a paint manufacturing company in Australia, and more recently became involved in a construction company in Bolivia.

Sergio is a Senior Lecturer it Marketing at the University of Otago in New Zealand, he is also currently a visiting fellow at MGSM where he aims to extend his research on business relationships. His research interests are in the dynamics of business-to-business relationships, interaction in business networks, the creation and implementation of business solutions, and supply chain integration and collaboration.

What's the classroom experience like?
Sergio uses a case-based pedagogy.  He introduces students to a broad range of marketing concepts (e.g., stretching into product logistics); supplies outside readings and cases; and devotes class time to student-driven discussions and analyses of data (e.g., case studies such as LG Electronics, Bolivia Coffee, Global Oil & Logistics, Firestone and the Global Wine Wars).
We are fortunate to include Sergio as a member 
of our Otago MBA faculty team. 

Monday, 19 May 2014

Conceptual Reasoning 3: classroom discussion


Thinking constitutes an acquired skill refined with practice.

Hi again guys,
I'm hoping that we can make the refinement of your conceptual reasoning skills fun.  
Here's an explanation.

Much of our course and project work centers on thinking conceptually: i.e., abstracting away from the immediate details of a situation to comprehend a problem and solution. We recognized this ability (to think in terms of concepts) as essential in student candidates and a central theme developed across courses, thereby helping you to refine this ability as you progress through our programme. It in part typifies the transformation we say should occur in our students. 
It may also be possible to turn this ability into a game.  As you interact in class, consider asking your peers the following question: 
  • What do you mean by…? 
  • How are you defining…? 
  • What assumptions are you making…? 
  • What is your basic premise / logic?
  • Can you abstract away from case details to clarify your argument?
  • Do you have credible sources to support your logic? 
  • Are you arguing from data points (symptoms of a problem)?
  • Are you arguing from experience?
  • Is that your opinion? (the same thing as arguing from experience)
  • Does your small-N logic generalize? 
  • Can you reasonably argue from analogy or metaphor?

 "All I hear is noise."


Conceptual Reasoning 2: Reading and Writing


Conceptual Reasoning
It has come to my attention that reading assignments are taking an inordinate amount of time; students are concerned about plagiarism (i.e., unknowingly violating rules); and they may be insufficiently distinguishing between description versus analysis in their reading and writing.  Here are some recommendations.

How to read (for speed and comprehension):
  1. Never read any course materials, articles or book chapters, from first line to last line. Professional materials are not stories, not read descriptively, and not read to fulfill an obligation.
  2. Read the abstract, introduction and conclusion (first).
  3. Analyse course materials, looking for specific information: concepts, definitions, and logic structure.
  4. Identify boundary / context limitations (e.g., interpersonal leadership vs. leadership at a distance - through social media).
  5. As a secondary concern, review any applications of the logic to data (e.g., examples or case studies).
  6. Compare treatments of concepts, definitions and logic structure across readings.  You may consider constructing a table: left column for concepts; middle for definitions, logic, context; and right column for personal notes / insights.
How to write as a scholar & professional:
  1. Analyze the lecturer's instructions for key concepts and questions.  What is the lecturer asking?
  2. Demonstrate a scholarly understanding of these concepts in any written assessment or exam question, including defining concepts and referencing appropriate course materials.  
  3. The greatest concern about plagiarism will arise when you're interacting with, or borrowing from, course materials. 
  4. Identify any boundary conditions: "My analysis will focus on X in such-and-such context, and not address issues pertaining to Y or alternative contexts."  Lecturers appreciate the clarity of structure.
  5. Quite often the lecturer will require you to apply course concepts to data (e.g., reflection on a personal experience or case study) with a specific context. 
  6. Analyze the data (case study) using your conceptual understanding; do not describe.  This should be entirely your work, with references included only to back up your arguments. 
  7. ***Remember, separate your scholarly analysis of the concepts from your application of concepts to data!
A student once asked, "Yeah, but how does this relate to the real world?"  My response, "You call it the real world; I call it messy data."  
Your job as a business professional is to abstract away from the noise and confusion (e.g., excess immediate, irrelevant information + opinion); structure the problem in a professional literature; and follow the recommended analyses to find a solution.  Ideally, you will back up any argument you create with data (quantitative analyses + interviews with industry experts) from the real world. 


Conceptual Reasoning 1: and its application

Conceptual Reasoning
This blog post is for our students (the focus audience); all others
 may feel free to listen in.  

Hey guys,

You've completed your first major writing assignment and soon face end-of-term projects and exams.  A sufficient context exists to explain conceptual reasoning and its application to (1) reading course materials and (2) writing as a scholar/professional.  In this post, I want to describe how the brain processes sensory data into percepts (i.e., meaningful perceptual representations of the world), experiences and concepts arising from experience.  I'll emphasize the following critical insight:
Experiences informs your gut feelings (i.e., intuition), but your experience-based conceptual understanding of the world (i.e., knowledge based on one lifetime) remains opinion and inadequate to call yourself a professional.  You need to ground your thinking in established bodies of knowledge (e.g., marketing, finance, Org. Leadership, etc.); you do not get to make the world up from scratch.
 Goethe put it this way, "He who cannot draw on three thousand of years human 
history lives from hand to mouth." ...a subsistence existence.

Here goes. All sensory data (except olfactory) enters the brain through the thalamus and is channeled to primary sensory cortices (V1 for vision). V1 neurons process the same minute details of any visual stimuli: they code for orientation at a point in space and spatial frequency of stimuli at that location. No meaningful, big-picture pixelated representation of the world exists.

These data advance along the ventral visual pathway to the Inferior Temporal Cortex (ITC), where percepts (meaningful visual representations) are recognized and stored. This is where you recognize people (including specific individuals), places and things.  These data undergo additional processing in an associative hierarchy and are integrated into meaningful experiences in the hippocampus; you remember emotion-laden events that trace the important moment in your life.

The hippocampus is also recognized as the nexus between percepts and concepts. For instance, learned associations between stimuli arise from statistical regularities in your environment (e.g., person + place = barista), and these regularities prove beneficial for predicting and interpreting future sensory data.  Try this: think about a rugby field and picture the things you would expect to see: white lines, goals, players, bleachers and fans.  You see these things, infer, "rugby," and adjust your behavior accordingly. This kind of experience-based learning is essential, but only carries you so far.

Leadership, justice and trust comprise the three (multidimensional) concepts (the focus) of Julia Richardson's Organizational Leadership course.  Now, based on your experience, you may somewhat grasp the meaning of these higher-order concepts.  Maybe you've known someone who demonstrated leadership, but any experience-based reasoning remains hand-to-mouth and inadequate for our MBA education.  We encourage you to share experiences in the classroom, but you should remember, experience-based reasoning is:

  1. based on a small N sample (N = one).
  2. essentially arguing from opinion (bad, very bad, wrong).
  3. with very limited generalizability (change the context and your experience loses value).    

We ask you to:
  1. abstract away from complex business problems.
  2. ground your thinking in established bodies of knowledge (course materials).
  3. define key concepts (from course materials) as a foundation for constructing logical arguments.
  4. Use course materials for in class discussions, written assignments and exams.
  5. And, appropriately reference your sources.
I know, my explanation of the brain is abbreviated and crude but, if you want a
more thorough explanation, you'll need to ask me nicely.

Cheers,  David


Monday, 28 April 2014

The Otago MBA: update


Our MBA students have settled into their routines and, from all reports, have embraced the expectation of actively contributing to the classroom experience.  Our MBA 38 class has gelled and all students are enthusiastically engaging in discussions, suggesting that the Power of Introverts Ted Talk may have helped to embolden our more reflective students.

Julia Richardson introduced her Organizational Leadership class to Intelligent Leadership Theory, a "who, what and why" overarching framework to students; discussed motivation and transformational leadership, (see Steven Jobs' Stanford Commencement Speech, below); and has emphasizing the critical nature of trust and justice in leadership.   Each reading for Julia's course introduces a specific perspective (i.e., definition and logic) on leadership (or motivation) with each perspective having legitimacy: no one right interpretation of leadership exists. The students were then asked to applied these materials to their first case, designed (as practice) to refine their ability to apply an academic frame to a complex business problem.

Julia reports that our MBA students enthusiastically engage in discussions, at times precluding mid-class breaks. They continue to refine their conceptual reasoning abilities, distinguishing between alternative definitions of leadership, as well as the value of alternative perspective to business practice.  The first syndicate case analysis went very well, with Julia reporting that our students conducted the best analysis she has ever seen: better than analyses of her Masters HR students at York University



Paul Hansen began his course with a focus on learning to think as an economist; he has strongly encouraged students to listen to NZ National Radio and starts each class with a chat about economic and/or political topics in the news.  The students have discussed the possible “tech wreck” as technology firms overseas (e.g. FaceBook & LinkedIn) and in NZ (e.g. Xero & PacificEdge) experience falling share prices.  They have also examined the link between the NZ Reserve Bank's increase in the Official Cash Rate (see RBNZ - ORC) to 3 percent and the response in the NZ dollar exchange rate versus the U.S. dollar.

Paul's contribution to the class has focused on the macroeconomic environment, with an analysis of New Zealand's transition from a regulated Welfare State (with a sixty-six percent tax rate) to a market-driven economy as a case study (see six-part Revolution).  Weekly tests scores indicate that all students in Paul's class are performing well.  Next up, Multi-Criteria Decision-Making and Conjoint Analysis.

Beth Rose continues to coax her students through an understanding of the research process, with both descriptive and exploratory analyses. The students have used SPSS to conduct cross tab analyses and are currently engaged in regressions analyses and modeling.  Beth reports that the nervousness of mastering stats has past and everyone seems to be performing well.


Friday, 4 April 2014

Shared Enquiry: the path to becoming a self-reliant thinker

Shared Enquiry
Shared Enquiry = the path to becoming a self-reliant thinker
Right answers do not exist in MBA-level discussions; everyone
in the classroom should actively engage in the discovery of knowledge.

The Otago MBA management team and our lecturers subscribe to an active learning model in which students participate in the learning process and daily practice their thinking skills, while demonstrating the ability to apply course material (e.g., marketing, finance, organizational leadership, economics, statistics) to complex business problems. In other words, we encourage shared enquiry as the path to becoming a self-reliant thinker, someone who can express him or herself with clarity and conviction; who can think conceptually (e.g., identify and define key terms); as well as contribute to the collaborative discovery of a deeper understanding of fundamental challenges facing global businesses.

Our students are asked to adhere to essential guidelines for engaging in productive discourse in our small seminar-style classes:
  • Resist overly quick judgements
  • Avoid arguing from small-N experience (e.g., we did it this way) and opinion
  • Support your reasoning using credible references (e.g., course materials)
  • Relate comments to the ongoing discussion
  • Strive for dialogue rather than a monologue
  • Seek to include all others in the conversation
  • Do not direct all discussions through the lecturer
  • Consider questions as a good way to enter the conversation
  • Avoid dominating with comments that are too lengthy or of little interest to others
  • Use courtesy and civility in all communications
  • Feel encouraged to continue lively debates outside the classroom
I will have more to say about the importance of building powerful thinking
skills in future posts: we consider this as fundamental to the transformation our students
experience in our programme.

Cheers,

David

Sunday, 9 March 2014

Our Otago MBA Graduates


We begin the Otago MBA by selecting the right candidates and then we strive to educate the whole person, with emphasis given to the student's reasoning abilities and character.  The question remains: "What should a graduate of our MBA programme look like?"  We adhere to a well-designed Assurance of Learning (AoL) programme that ties student assessments (course-by-course) to specific learning objects and cumulatively aligns with the following graduate student profile.  
As a professional, we expect our students to demonstrate maturity, experience and self-motivation. They should possess clearly articulated career ambitions; embrace “scary” challenges as growth opportunities; work well independently or confidently alongside seasoned professionals; as well as deftly network with business colleagues (e.g., through social media).
As a scholar, our graduates should demonstrate the ability to think conceptually within relevant business disciplines (e.g., economics, finance, marketing, human capital, operational excellence or international business), as well as within practical professional literatures (e.g., sustainability, leadership, and ethics).  They should possess the ability to capture complex business problems in a credible business frame; express an independent voice in business discussions; and make a genuine intellectual contribution to strategic decisions.
As an effective communicator, our graduates should possess the ability to construct well-crafted arguments in professional presentations; express him or herself efficiently and fluently in written documents; confidently express independent opinions with business colleagues; identify appropriate / relevant business analysis; translate those analyses into quantitative methods; and confidently support arguments with accurate, rigorous and reliable data.
As a leader, our graduates should demonstrate character (e.g., remain ethical and honest); slow the world down to think critically, thoughtfully and reflectively; remain respectful of individual and cultural differences; positively impact others (i.e., adhere to a Hippocratic Oath: Above all, do no harm); demonstrate refined interpersonal skills (e.g., manage relationships); overcome difficulties and work without trauma; accept prediction errors as learning opportunities; and remain coachable: listen and accept advice/guidance.
We emphasize consistent themes across our core programme with the intention of
instilling these skills and qualities in our students: a transformation occurs
 as they near graduation.

Cheers,

David

Tuesday, 21 January 2014

The 540 Professional Consulting Engagement: the Proposal

Otago MBA - Project Proposal

To current and future students:  A common scenario plays out in the 540 experience.  Our student meets with the client and is bombarded with overwhelming immediate, context-specific information, enough to make his or her head spin. It is the student's job to bring this information back and allow us to help structure a suitable project. We abstract away from the immediate and irrelevant data to ask, “What kind of problem is this?” We separate the noise (e.g., opinion and situational details) from a credible understanding of the problem and solutions.

Then, our students (you) work with the Academic Leader to structure a two-page formal project proposal consistent with our standard template, available from me.  The proposal constitutes an informal contract between you and the Otago MBA concerning the 540 requirements for graduation: this is an internal document only and not for circulation to the client.

The proposal also represents a very important working document intended to remove the grey and confusing mess of a complex business situation and add clarity. The proposal should provide sufficient structure to allow you to work efficiently in collecting data and completing your analyses. We do not want you to grope your way through the project.

Your proposal will contain the following: information about you, client profile, current challenge, your project (description, purpose, objectives, scope of work, and methods), schedule of deliverables, start and finish dates, as well as contact information for your client.
  • Client profile: Offer a short (two or three sentence) profile of the client, emphasizing information required to understand the challenge this company or non-profit agency faces: create a context. 
  • Current challenge: Briefly describe the complex business problem, a challenge, this company faces (e.g., increased competition, lagging performance or untapped market – the reason for your project.
  • Academic frame: Capture the challenge in an appropriate business frame (e.g., marketing, finance, economics, operations, strategy, sustainability or international business) that informs your methods and analyses (e.g., right data, collection methods and data analyse). 
  • Any 540 project focuses on business concepts. Some concepts delimit the project scope (this product or those competitors), while other concepts are defined by your analyses. You need to clearly identify the concepts of focus for your analyses.
  • Project description: You next describe the project scope, purpose and objectives for your analyses.
  • Define the project scope based on concepts: limited to this market (countries), performance (financial), operations (supply chain) or other concepts / delimiters that enable you to focus your work.  The purpose defines the intended benefit to your client and objectives describe the specific questions addressed.
  • Methods: Every project requires the student to collect and analyse data. You should include hard data whenever possible and may conduct content analyses (i.e., of annual reports), a survey (i.e., questionnaire data) or interviews with key constituents or industry experts.
  • Clearly describe (1) the data; (2) how you will collect data; (3) specific research tool – an interview instrument; (4) sources of data; and (5) how you will analyse the data.
At this point, you should have a well-honed grasp of the work required to complete your 540 project with minimal wasted effort.  Please ask if you have any questions.  

Future students: Few opportunities exist in your professional career to perform on a big stage,
with the spotlight on you and the backing of professionals who will help you look good.
This is your chance to advance your career or make a transition to a new career.


David



Monday, 20 January 2014

Back to Work: the 540 professional consulting engagement

Otago MBA  - Queenstown Adventure
Queenstown - Lake Wakatipu
The holiday's over and it's time to get back to work.  You may have surmised from previous posts that our 2013 Phase One coursework has ended and our MBA 37 students are either completing Phase Two electives through an Int'l exchange (e.g., at Duke and UNC) or starting their 540 consulting engagement. Most students will enhance their marketability with both an Int'l exchange and project, but they have some flexibility about the timing of these endeavors.

It is my intention to allow future students to "peek inside the Otago MBA," so we (our students and I) plan to open up our discussion of current projects to you. You can listen in and direct questions to me. This format for discussion has two benefits for us: 1) I do not need to repeat explanations N times; and 2) our students can learn from each other. Students face the challenge of completing the 540 project away from Dunedin and separate from their MBA support network: something we can address here.  For you, our future students, this is what you need to know up front:

Preparation for the BUSI 540 project begins the moment the student walks through our front door.  The Otago MBA programme is designed as an integrated educational experience from orientation to 540 business project, with core courses introducing students to relevant academic disciplines, business analyses and quantitative methods; and professional development activities affording opportunities to clarify career ambitions, hone professional skills and build a network. 
The formal project process begins with a conversation between you and the Academic Leader (me) about your career ambitions: “What do you want to do with your career?” and “Where do you want to go?” 
We then work with you to identify a suitable client and project aligned with your career interests and with an appropriate intellectual challenge.
It is your responsibility to find a sponsor (your contact) in a corporate or nonprofit client (oftentimes with our assistance), gain an understanding of the client’s operation, and map a well-defined challenge this organization faces.
Please be aware, the client does not define the project. Clients are oftentimes confused (why they need our help), define the project in terms of a solution, and lack the ability to capture the work in an appropriate academic frame.
You will need to think through the challenge (i.e., a complex business problem), ask a lot of questions and push back on your client to steer the project in an appropriate direction. We (our MBA team and professional educators) assist in this process.
Most of our MBA 37 students have identified a client and are currently drafting a proposal for their project.  You should now have a suitable frame for grasping the conversations that will occur under a common title: The 540 Professional Consulting Engagement. 
 Cheers,

David

Friday, 3 January 2014

Meet our Otago MBA Team: Professor Denis Kobzev

Otago MBA: Visiting Professor Denis Kobzov
Professor Denis Kobzev
All elements of our business model must fit together to deliver best value to our customers:
 this includes the selection of professional educators we place in the classroom. 

I would like to introduce Denis Kobzev, a thoughtful friend and gifted educator who has earned the respect
of our Otago MBA management team and students. Denis holds the positions of Director of Business Education, Leeds Trinity University, UK; Associate Fellow, Operations Management Group, Warwick Business School, UK; and Visiting Professor in our Otago MBA: teaching Operational Excellence.

Denis brings a broad base of global, practical knowledge into the classroom through his experiences in senior management positions at international giants Procter & Gamble and Schering Plough. Denis can also boast prior involvement in business / development projects in Europe, Middle East and Africa in collaboration with corporate partners (e.g., ASDA, Aushan, Migros, IBM, Accenture, HSBC and BT Group), as well as the United Nations and World Health Organization.

Denis has aided in the design of leading management programmes in Germany, Russia, Norway and Australia. He views the active exchange of knowledge among experienced professionals as "the heart of a good MBA programme." Last year, Denis designed an experiment in collaboration with Olga Meglinskaya, our Curriculum Delivery Manager, to promote critical reasoning through peer assessment. He asked our students to sport a different (uncomfortable) hat and critique the reasoning of peers, and thereby learn to refine their own thinking abilities. The experiment was a valuable contribution to our programme.



We depend on the talents of gifted educators like Denis to
deliver best value to our MBA students.

Cheers, David

 

Thursday, 26 December 2013

Our Classroom: the Power of Introverts





Everyone Contributes Valuable Insights!

In a prior post, I emphasized the importance of active learning and the collaborative discovery of
knowledge through shared inquiry in our classes.   Some of our students may remain reflective by nature; others may initially feel hesitant to speak in class; still others may face the challenge of thinking in one
language (e.g., Chinese) before translating thoughts into English; and differences in
culture may compel others to remain respectfully quiet.

I have included the "Power of Introverts" Ted Talk to embolden our more reflective students
and encourage more vocal students to remain culturally sensitive, respect everyone's
right to participate and strive for an inclusive learning experience.

Thank you,

David


Tuesday, 24 December 2013

Back to our Business Model: conceptual reasoning

Ruins of an old farm
One of my favorite photographs owing to the lighting and
complementary colors: taken south of Dunedin
Time to get back to our business model.  I have explained: (1) we remain a boutique MBA programme (by choice) to deliver best value to our students and concede we remain beneath the radar of Top 100 rankings; (2) we are selective about whom we allow into our programme (less than 1 in 10) and resist compromising our standards for size; (3) our unique value proposition emphasizes accelerating your career in the global economy, both through facilitating a transformation in you as a business professional and using our project work to get you into the right industry, corporation and/or professional network; (4) we eschew placement in favor of rigorously training and supporting our students in pursuit of their career ambitions; and (5) our students practice their thinking skills daily in the classroom on the way to becoming truly powerful individuals who can express themselves with clarity and conviction.


All of the pieces of a business model must fit together to deliver best value.


Now, I'll elaborate on the notion of conceptual reasoning and how we develop this ability.  Our core courses (phase one, on-campus programme) focus either on building quantitative skills or thinking within credible business disciplines: e.g., content areas of economics, marketing or sustainability.  Content courses introduce concepts, but the precise definitions of these concepts vary from one course to the next: e.g., the definition of a market in economics vs. in marketing or performance in finance vs. sustainability.  Indeed, much of business revolves around a small number of concepts: market, customer, product (encompassing service), industry, competitor, competition, strategy, business model, performance, cost (plus cost structure), capital (including human capital), financial & physical assets, production/operations, transaction, organization form, ownership structure and so forth. 

Here's a critical insight: most business problems can be structured by identifying the concepts involved; the relevant business discipline needed to structure your thinking; and the appropriate analyses to support informed decision making.  It sounds simple but the challenge is to abstract away from the immediate details of a business situation (i.e., noise) to think conceptually, an acquired ability.

We emphasize conceptual thinking (or reasoning) as a theme across courses, thereby helping students to refine this ability as they progress through our programme, but I'll emphasize two critical experience that directly bear on challenging your reasoning.  First, our Strategic Planning course taught by our much loved Richard Higham, challenges your "dominant paradigm" or the concepts and definitions used to inform your thinking. Second, our high-level project work (e.g., Live Case & capstone consulting engagement) requires you to define the scope of work in terms of key concepts.  As stated in our BUSI 540 course outline:  
"Any 540 project we conduct focuses on business concepts.  Some concepts delimit the project scope (this product or those competitors), while other concepts are defined by your analyses.  Indeed, an entire 50-page report may focus on defining one concept (e.g., what is the market?).  In this regard, you advance knowledge (make an intellectual contribution) by defining / describing some core business concepts more precisely than anyone has before—and you inform your definition (of the market) with data." 
When you're ready to get started, let us know.

David

Wednesday, 18 December 2013

The Classroom: a focus on thinking


Governors Cafe, George St., Dunedin, NZ
Dunedin is a city of small cafes, cozy restaurants and friends
well-suited for good conversation.
I've been a professional educator for more than twenty-five years and this topic, the classroom experience, is one about which I am passionate. You would think that, over twenty-five years, pedagogies would change and we (as educators) would become more effective in facilitating learning. Yet, too often teachers, a term very loosely defined, continue to lecture at students who passively take notes under the premise that this person is providing right answers (i.e., pearls of wisdom) concerning whatever problem businesses may face: the idea is pure nonsense.

Not at the Otago MBA!

Remember, "right" answers do not exist in MBA-level discussions and everyone
in the classroom should actively engage in the discovery of knowledge.


The Otago MBA management team subscribes to an active learning model in which students participate in the learning process and daily practice their thinking skills, while demonstrating the ability to apply course material (e.g., from marketing, finance, economics) to complex business problems. In other words, we encourage shared inquiry as the path to becoming a self-reliant thinker, someone who can express him or herself with clarity and conviction; who can think conceptually (e.g., identify and define key terms); as well as contribute to the collaborative discovery of a deeper understanding of fundamental questions facing global businesses.

Our students are asked to adhere to essential guidelines for engaging in productive discourse in our small seminar-style classes:
  • Resist overly quick judgments
  • Avoid arguing from small-N experience (e.g., we did it this way) and opinion
  • Support your reasoning using credible references (e.g., course materials)
  • Relate comments to the ongoing discussion
  • Strive for dialogue rather than a monologue
  • Seek to include all others in the conversation
  • Do not direct all discussions through the lecturer
  • Consider questions as a good way to enter the conversation
  • Avoid dominating with comments that are too lengthy or of little interest to others
  • Use courtesy and civility in all communications
  • Feel encouraged to continue lively debates outside the classroom

I will have much more to say about the importance of building powerful thinking
 skills in future posts: we consider this as fundamental to the transformation our students
 experience in our programme.



As always, I invite you to apply now.

David